With more than half of the 2026 NFL season in the books and two months left until the playoffs begin, some teams are already feeling buyer's remorse over offseason moves they made that haven't worked out.
For others, big risks have paid off and turned good teams into bona fide Super Bowl contenders.
Here are nine of the biggest moves of the NFL's 2026 offseason re-graded after the first 10 weeks of regular-season action:
Chiefs sign RB Kenneth Walker

Grade: B
Just a few weeks ago, this addition would've deserved an A-plus.
Walker wasted no time making an impact in Kansas City, racking up 760 yards from scrimmage and eight touchdowns during the Chiefs' 5-0 start. The former Super Bowl MVP looked like the early favorite for Offensive Player of the Year and the missing piece in Kansas City's rejuvenation.
The problem is that Walker not only couldn't keep finding that level of success in losses to the Seahawks and Broncos, but a minor groin injury also opened the door for Emmett Johnson to start in his place. The fifth-round rookie looked like an instant star as the fill-in, finishing with 171 yards and two touchdowns in Kansas City's win against the Falcons.
While the Chiefs are a better team with Walker on the roster, would they still dish out $43 million to a running back if they knew they were about to find a rookie capable of making the kind of plays that Johnson has made?
Ravens nix DE Maxx Crosby trade, sign DE Trey Hendrickson

Grade: C+
The good news for Baltimore is that completing the trade to acquire Crosby almost definitely would've aged poorly. With Lamar Jackson and Tyler Huntley both on injured reserve, the Ravens have lost five straight, and their postseason hopes are dwindling fast. This season is looking more and more like a lost cause, and Baltimore should be happy it didn't send away 2026 and 2027 first-round picks for a costly veteran.
The bad news is that Hendrickson hasn't done much. With a four-year, $112-million investment, the Ravens certainly hoped the former Bengals pass-rusher would have more than two sacks at this point. That deal is looking like a significant mistake, but finishing the Crosby trade would've been an even bigger one.
Rams trade for DE Myles Garrett, CB Trent McDuffie

Grade: B
The Rams gave up a ridiculous amount to add two of the NFL's best defensive players. To get Garrett, Los Angeles sent the Browns a 2027 first-round pick, a 2028 second-rounder, and a 2029 third-rounder, along with 26-year-old, two-time Pro Bowl pass-rusher Jared Verse. For McDuffie, the Rams gave the Chiefs their 2026 first-, fifth-, and sixth-round selections, plus a 2027 third-round pick.
Was all of that worth it? It's hard to say.
McDuffie has been excellent. According to PFF, quarterbacks have a 29.1 passer rating when targeting the star cornerback in coverage, and he still hasn't allowed a touchdown this season.
Garrett struggled through a poor Week 1 before landing on injured reserve. In his return to action, he destroyed the Commanders with a three-sack performance that may have been the biggest reason the Rams won.
Los Angeles' defense has been one of the NFL's best this season, but all of those picks will be sorely missed if Garrett can't stay healthy and the team doesn't make a Super Bowl run.
Patriots trade for WR A.J. Brown

Grade: D-
Nothing about this trade is looking good for the Patriots. For the price of a 2027 fifth-round pick and a 2028 first-rounder, New England inherited a pricey receiver who can't stay healthy or do much on the field.
In four games in the lineup, Brown hasn't finished a contest with more than three receptions despite 26 targets. He's rarely been open, struggled with drops, and fumbled one of the only 11 times he actually had the ball.
As former Patriots All-Pro cornerback Asante Samuel described it, Brown "literally forgot how to play football."
With Drake Maye done for the year and Tommy DeVito taking over at quarterback, the odds of the acquisition looking any better in the last two months of the season are pretty slim.
Bengals trade for DT Dexter Lawrence

Grade: B+
After allowing the most rushing yards in the NFL last season, Cincinnati took the biggest swing possible to fix the problem. For the No. 10 pick in the 2026 NFL Draft, the Bengals acquired Lawrence to anchor the middle of their defensive line.
Are they an elite run defense now? Not even close.
Cincinnati is allowing 5.0 yards per carry this season, the second-most behind only the Cowboys. That's not due to Lawrence, though. He's not only been a good run-stuffer for the club, but he's also proving to be one of the team's best pass-rushers, with five sacks and eight quarterback hits this season.
Lawrence hasn't single-handedly fixed the Bengals' defense, but with the team gearing up for a postseason run, it's a deal they'd probably do again in a heartbeat.
Broncos trade for WR Jaylen Waddle

Grade: C
After a solid first two years with Bo Nix at quarterback, the Broncos hoped adding another dynamic receiving threat would elevate their young passer to the next level. Instead, Denver went from the No. 10 offense a year ago to the No. 30 offense so far in 2026.
The Broncos have struggled to get their passing game going, and Waddle has been good but not great for his new team. While he's Denver's leading receiver with 30 receptions for 337 yards, he's also in the NFL's top 10 in drops, with four. That's not the production and quality the Broncos hoped for when they traded away a first-round pick and change to the Dolphins.
Bills trade for WR D.J. Moore

Grade: B+
Buffalo paid much less for Moore than the Broncos spent on Waddle, giving up a second-round pick and receiving a fifth-rounder from Chicago in return.
In seven games on the field, Moore has 23 receptions for 375 yards and a team-leading three touchdowns. For the NFL's highest-scoring offense, Moore has been Josh Allen's favorite deep threat, with the average throw in his direction coming 17 yards downfield.
Though Khalil Shakir and Dalton Kincaid remain the Bills' top two targets and Moore's numbers aren't eye-popping, he's been the added element Buffalo needed.
Panthers sign OLB Jaelan Phillips

Grade: B-
No player made more money in free agency during the 2026 offseason than Phillips, who signed a four-year, $120-million deal with Carolina. With 3.5 sacks so far, that contract doesn't jump off the page as a wise investment. However, those numbers don't tell the whole story.
After missing three weeks with a hamstring injury, Phillips dominated the Panthers' pivotal Week 10 win against the Saints. He earned NFC Defensive Player of the Week honors after finishing with eight quarterback pressures, a sack, a forced fumble, and another sack that was wiped out by an iffy horse-collar call. Carolina has also been much better against the run with Phillips in the lineup.
If Phillips provides more performances like his last outing, he'll validate the Panthers' investment.
Raiders sign QB Kirk Cousins

Grade: A
Although Cousins is the only player on this list already on another team, the Raiders have no reason to regret their free-agent addition. The 38-year-old quarterback was always going to be a temporary starter while Las Vegas waited for the right time to hand the reins to Fernando Mendoza. The Raiders signed Cousins in early April, when it was already a foregone conclusion that Mendoza would be their No. 1 overall pick in the 2026 NFL Draft.
In his nine starts, Cousins led the Raiders to a 4-5 record with 20 touchdowns and eight interceptions. That's not exactly spectacular, but it was productive enough to let Las Vegas stick to its plan of not tossing Mendoza into the fire ahead of schedule. And when it came time to turn to the rookie, the Raiders got a third-round pick from the Vikings to part with the veteran. A couple more wins would've been ideal, but the Raiders got their money's worth and more from Cousins.
Adam Stites is a contributing writer for theScore.














